PM Solutions

PM Solutions provides project management consulting, training, and resources to help organizations improve performance and deliver critical projects successfully. 

Project Management Solutions News Archive 2006

Report: Identifying and Recovering Troubled Projects Can Save Companies Millions


New research from PM Solutions' Center for Business Practices confirms risk that troubled projects pose to organizations

HAVERTOWN, PA (April 19, 2006) – Over the next twelve months, organizations that average closing $65 million worth of projects will see $30 million of those projects at risk of failing. That risk can be mitigated if the organization has in place a standard process for reviewing and recovering their troubled projects. These and other conclusions are among the findings detailed in a new report from the Center for Business Practices (CBP), the research arm of project management consultancy PM Solutions.

The CBP's report, "Troubled Projects: Project Failure or Project Recovery," polled 84 senior project management practitioners about the health of their organizations' projects and efforts to turn troubled projects around. According to the study, approximately 42% of organizations' projects are troubled, and fewer than half of the organizations had a project recovery intervention in the past three years to mitigate the risk of failure. In addition, only 24% of the organizations had a standard process in place for recognizing and recovering these troubled projects, increasing the likelihood of significant loss.

There is good news, however, in the study's findings. Project recovery interventions were found to have an 80% success rate, either with the projects recovered and completed successfully (in 43% of organizations) or by setting new project expectations and meeting those new requirements successfully (in 37% of organizations).

"What's promising about the study results is that organizations with a standard recovery process have 83% more successful projects, 195% fewer troubled projects, and 120% fewer failed projects," said Jim Pennypacker, director of the CBP. "Companies can avert failure in the first place if they have an established process for reviewing their existing projects, identifying projects that are in trouble, and recovering them before they get significantly derailed."

A troubled project is one that (plus or minus acceptable variances) exceeds the estimated budget, is behind the estimated schedule, does not meet expected requirements, or has unacceptable overall project quality.

In addition, the study identifies the leading causes of troubled projects:

  • Expectations that are too high, unrealistic, not managed, or poorly communicated
  • Requirements that are unclear, contradictory, ambiguous, or imprecise
  • A lack of agreement on requirements or disagreement as to priority
  • A lack of resources, resource conflicts, turnover of key resources, or poor resource planning
  • Planning that is based on insufficient data, missing items, insufficient details, or poor estimates

About the Center for Business Practices®
The Center for Business Practices (www.cbponline.com) is the research and publishing arm of the management consulting and training organization PM Solutions. The CBP promotes effective strategy execution through sound portfolio, program, project, and performance management by capturing best practice knowledge and integrating it into actionable, fact-based information available through research reports, books, and benchmarking events.

About PM Solutions
PM Solutions is a management consulting, training, and research firm dedicated to helping companies optimize business performance and successfully execute their strategies through project management improvement initiatives. Core services include on-demand project and program staffing, remote project controls support, project portfolio management, organizational project management maturity assessments, process and methodology development, project office deployment and enhancement, value measurement, project recovery, and corporate training delivered through the PM College® (www.pmcollege.com). Headquartered near Philadelphia, Pa., USA, PM Solutions' diverse client roster includes some of the world's leading organizations.